When ad results drop, it's tempting to blame Andromeda. Sometimes that's right. More often the cause is creative fatigue, tracking, season or the offer. This 30-point audit helps you find the real cause, and the recovery plan shows what to do about it.
"Our ads stopped working after Andromeda" is one of the most common things we hear. Meta Andromeda really did change what works, but it's rarely the only cause. This audit walks through 30 checks in six areas, then the self-assessment scores your account and points to a recovery plan.
Area 1: Tracking (checks 1 to 5)
- Does each purchase or lead fire once, not twice? Duplicate pixels are common after theme or app changes.
- Do purchase events carry the correct value and currency?
- Is the Conversions API sending events alongside the pixel?
- Do Ads Manager results roughly match real orders or leads over a week?
- Did anything change recently: checkout app, website, domain, consent banner?
Tracking problems look exactly like algorithm problems, but no creative fix will solve them. See the ad tracking guide.
Area 2: Creative (checks 6 to 12)
- How many genuinely different concepts are live? One or two is a red flag.
- Are most ads variations of one image or video?
- Is one ad taking nearly all the spend?
- Is frequency rising while results fall? That's ad fatigue.
- When did you last add a brand-new concept?
- Do ads show different kinds of buyers and reasons to buy?
- Is hook rate or CTR falling on your main ads?
Fix: creative diversification and a steady testing rhythm.
Area 3: Structure (checks 13 to 17)
- How many ad sets share the same goal? More than three is often too many.
- Do ad sets overlap in audience?
- Does your main ad set get enough results to leave the learning phase?
- Are you editing budgets, audiences or ads daily?
- Are old duplicates of winning ad sets competing with each other?
Fix: consolidate your campaign structure.
Area 4: Targeting (checks 18 to 21)
- Are ad sets limited by narrow interests or tight lookalikes?
- Is Advantage+ audience on, with your audiences as suggestions?
- Is the location right, including where buyers actually live?
- Are exclusions accidentally removing good buyers?
Fix: targeting after Andromeda.
Area 5: Budget and bidding (checks 22 to 25)
- Is the daily budget at least two to three times your target cost per result?
- Did you raise budgets suddenly (more than about 20 percent at once)?
- Are bid caps or cost caps set too tight, limiting delivery?
- Is it a high-CPM period (Diwali, big sales, wedding season)?
See the ad budget guide and CPM.
Area 6: Offer and landing page (checks 26 to 30)
- Has a competitor launched a better price or offer?
- Are hero products in stock, in all sizes?
- Does the landing page load fast on a phone?
- Are price, delivery time and returns clear before checkout?
- For leads: is follow-up fast, and are leads actually being called?
See conversion rate optimisation, landing pages and why leads don't pick up.
Self-assessment · about 2 minutes
Meta Andromeda account audit
Score your account on the six areas above. Answer for the last 30 days.
1. Tracking: are purchases or leads firing once, with correct values, matching real numbers?
2. Creative: how many genuinely different concepts are live?
3. Creative: when did you add a brand-new concept?
4. Structure: how many ad sets share your main goal?
5. Targeting: how restricted are your main ad sets?
6. Changes: how often do you edit budgets, audiences or ads?
7. Budget: is the daily budget at least 2–3x your target cost per result?
8. Offer and page: is your landing page fast, clear on price and delivery, with stock available?
Answer all 8 questions to see your result (0 done).
The recovery plan
- Week 1: tracking. Test and fix events. Don't judge anything else until this is done.
- Week 1–2: creative. Launch three to five genuinely different concepts.
- Week 2: structure. Build one broad ad set with your best and newest ads; move budget across gradually.
- Week 3: targeting. Remove narrow limits; keep only required controls.
- Week 4: review. Compare cost per real result with the previous month, adjusting for season.
When it really is a platform change
Sometimes results shift because Meta changed something, and many advertisers see it at once. If your audit is clean, keep a steady hand: avoid rebuilding everything in a panic, keep feeding new concepts, and judge over weeks rather than days. Most short-term swings settle.
Back to the main Andromeda guide for the full series. If you'd like a second pair of eyes, Varko offers a free 30-minute call where we look at your account with you. Book a free call or see how it works.
Frequently asked questions
Check tracking, frequency, season, stock and landing page first. If all are fine and your account is fragmented with little creative variety, Andromeda-related changes are likely to help.
Rarely all at once. Build the new structure alongside the old and move budget gradually, so you don't lose what's working.
Usually two to four weeks for new concepts and structure to settle, depending on budget and how many results you get.
Yes. On a free 30-minute call we'll look at your setup with you and tell you honestly what we'd change first.
Symptoms and likely causes
- Sudden drop overnight across all campaigns: tracking broken, payment issue, policy rejection, or a site outage. Check Events Manager and account alerts first.
- Gradual decline over weeks, frequency rising: creative fatigue. Add new concepts.
- Costs up, conversion rate unchanged: competition or season (CPM rising). Check timing against festivals and sales.
- Clicks fine, sales down: landing page, stock, price or checkout problems.
- Leads up, customers down: lead quality. Tighten forms, creative and follow-up, and send quality signals back.
- One ad takes all the spend, then stalls: too few distinct concepts.
- Results swing wildly day to day: too many small ad sets or too many edits.
Keep a change log
Most account mysteries are solved by knowing what changed and when. Keep a simple log: date, what changed (budget, ads, audience, website, prices, stock), why, and who did it. When results move, check the log before blaming the algorithm. It also stops the habit of making several changes at once, which makes it impossible to know which one helped or hurt.
An illustrative recovery
A coaching institute saw cost per lead rise 60 percent over two months and blamed Andromeda. The audit found: the lead event was firing twice on the thank-you page (so reported leads were inflated earlier and dropped when a plugin update fixed it), six ad sets split by interest, and three ads that were all versions of one poster. The fix was to verify tracking and reset expectations to the true baseline, consolidate into one broad ad set, and launch five new concepts: a teacher introduction, a student result story, a parent-focused fee explainer, a demo-class Reel and a hostel tour. Within four weeks, cost per enrolled student was lower than before the drop, even though cost per lead was only slightly better.
When to bring in help
- You've fixed tracking and structure, and results still haven't recovered after four to six weeks.
- You can't produce new concepts often enough.
- Ads take more time than you can give while running the business.
- Spend is high enough that small improvements are worth a lot.
Our guide to hiring an ads agency covers what to look for, and the red flags to avoid.
